Western red cedar or Leylandii for a conifer screen: the honest choice for Goodnestone gardens
If you need an evergreen screen and you are choosing a conifer, these two come up in almost every conversation: Leylandii (x Cuprocyparis leylandii) for its speed, or western red cedar (Thuja plicata) for what is often marketed as its greater manageability. The honest trade-off is more nuanced than the marketing suggests. Leylandii has real advantages that western red cedar cannot match. Western red cedar has one specific advantage over Leylandii that, in the right circumstances, outweighs everything else. This guide works through both sides squarely so you can decide which one actually suits your situation around Goodnestone or Chillenden.
What both conifers have in common
Both Leylandii and western red cedar are fast-growing, evergreen conifers used throughout east Kent as year-round screens against roads, neighbours, prevailing wind and overlooking windows. Both are sold as cell-grown or container plants from UK nurseries. Both clip well and are cold-hardy (RHS H7 for western red cedar; Leylandii is similarly tough on most UK sites). Neither is native, and neither qualifies as a "wildlife hedge" in the way that a hawthorn and blackthorn mix does. Neither is in any way related to the true cedars (Cedrus species) that you see as specimen trees in parkland. If you want a fast green wall, both will deliver one. The question is what that wall costs you to maintain, and what happens when something goes wrong.
The decision: Leylandii or western red cedar?
Pros of Leylandii (x Cuprocyparis leylandii)
- Fastest establishment of any UK hedging conifer. Young Leylandii plants in their second and third growing seasons can put on 60-90cm of growth per year in good conditions. On a free-draining chalky site around Goodnestone, a row of cell-grown plants at 60cm spacing will produce a useful visual screen within two to three growing seasons, and a substantial hedge within five. No other commonly available hedging plant matches that rate.
- Very low purchase cost. Cell-grown Leylandii plants are widely available from UK nurseries at 50p to £1.50 per plant in sizes small enough to establish quickly. Hedging a 30-metre run at 60cm spacing costs £25-£75 in plant material, making it accessible for long boundary runs where planting material cost is a real constraint.
- Dense, consistent evergreen cover from an early age. The close-textured, dark green foliage of a well-maintained Leylandii hedge gives solid screening from both sides with no seasonal gaps. If the purpose is simply to block a view or reduce wind, Leylandii does that job reliably once it reaches 1.5-2m.
- Responds well to clipping when young and green. On healthy young growth, Leylandii clips cleanly and tolerates being kept to a consistent face. The new growth that flushes after clipping is a noticeably brighter green than the older foliage, which gives a maintained Leylandii hedge a tidy, two-tone appearance in late summer.
Cons of Leylandii (x Cuprocyparis leylandii)
- Cannot regenerate from old, brown wood. This is not a minor caveat, it is the single most consequential fact about Leylandii. Cut a Leylandii hedge back past the green growing zone into older, browned-out internal wood, and those sections stay brown permanently. There is no second chance. If a hedge is allowed to grow too wide, or is cut badly on one face, the only options are accepting the bare patches, growing through them, or removing the hedge. Western red cedar does not share this characteristic to the same degree.
- Needs frequent clipping to stay manageable. The growth rate that is an advantage during establishment becomes a maintenance burden once the hedge has reached its intended size. A Leylandii hedge at 2m needs trimming two to three times per year to stay compact, not once. On a long run, that is a significant time and cost commitment every year.
- Subject to high-hedge legislation once it reaches 2m. The Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003 (Part 8) covers evergreen hedges over 2m that affect the light or amenity of a neighbouring property. A formal high-hedge complaint to Dover District Council costs £450 to file and, if upheld, requires the hedge to be reduced and kept to a specified height. Leylandii is the most common subject of such complaints in the UK. This matters particularly for boundary hedges that are close to neighbouring properties in the villages around Goodnestone.
- Can become a long-term liability. An overgrown, poorly maintained Leylandii hedge is one of the more difficult renovation challenges in domestic hedgework. Once the hedge has been allowed to grow beyond its green zone, staged reduction can help (see the guide on staged Leylandii reduction linked below), but it cannot reverse what has already been cut into brown. A Leylandii hedge that has been neglected for a decade or more sometimes has no viable renovation path, and the choice becomes between accepting the condition or removing it entirely.
Pros of western red cedar (Thuja plicata 'Atrovirens')
- Can be cut harder without permanent brown patches. This is the one practical advantage that genuinely separates western red cedar from Leylandii. Thuja plicata has a better ability to regenerate from older wood than Leylandii, meaning that if the hedge has been allowed to get slightly wider than intended, or if a section is cut further back than usual, the plant is more likely to produce new growth from that older wood than Leylandii would be. The margins on a western red cedar hedge are measurably more forgiving.
- Slower growth means less clipping once established. A western red cedar hedge grows at roughly 30-60cm per year on a typical UK site, compared with 60-90cm for Leylandii. Once it has reached its intended height, one or two clips per year is generally sufficient to keep it tidy. The annual maintenance commitment is noticeably lower than for Leylandii at the same size.
- Aromatic foliage. The foliage of Thuja plicata has a pleasant, resinous scent when clipped, which some people find attractive. This is not a horticultural reason to plant it, but it is a noticeable quality-of-life difference when the hedge is being maintained.
- More tolerant of shade and slightly wetter conditions than Leylandii. On plots around Goodnestone and Chillenden where part of the planting line runs under the partial shade of existing trees, or on lower ground where the soil holds moisture into spring, western red cedar establishes more reliably than Leylandii, which prefers an open, well-lit position.
- Finer, more formal texture when clipped. The spray-like foliage of Thuja 'Atrovirens' clips to a slightly denser, more refined face than Leylandii, which some owners find more aesthetically suitable for a formal kitchen garden or estate boundary than the coarser, more uniform profile of maintained Leylandii.
Cons of western red cedar (Thuja plicata)
- Takes longer to produce a screen. At 30-60cm growth per year, a western red cedar hedge takes four to six growing seasons to reach 2m from 60cm plants, compared with two to three seasons for Leylandii. If rapid screening is the priority, whether for privacy, wind shelter or roadside noise, western red cedar is a slower answer.
- More expensive to plant. Western red cedar cell-grown plants typically cost £1.50-£3.50 each, two to three times the cost of Leylandii at the same size. The difference adds up on a long run, and it is a real factor when plant material cost matters.
- The "cut back hard" advantage has real limits. The claim that western red cedar can be cut back freely into old wood is true compared with Leylandii but not unlimited. Cutting back to completely bare, dry, dead internal wood is still likely to produce permanent brown patches. The forgiving zone is deeper than in Leylandii, not infinite. Owners who plant western red cedar expecting never to have a renovation problem if they leave it long enough are misinformed.
- Susceptible to Thuja blight and Phytophthora on poorly drained ground. The RHS notes that Thuja plicata can be affected by Phytophthora root rot. On heavy, waterlogged clay soils, this is a genuine risk. The chalky boulder clay around Goodnestone drains reasonably well on the higher ground, but lower-lying plots that sit wet through winter may favour neither conifer, and a different hedging species altogether would be the more sensible choice.
- Can brown off on exposed, cold-facing sites in a hard winter. Thuja 'Atrovirens' is cold-hardy (RHS H7), but exposed north- or east-facing positions with no shelter from cold drying winds can produce some winter bronzing of the foliage on the exposed face. It usually recovers, but it can look ragged between late winter and the first flush of new growth in spring.
Which to choose: the two questions that decide it
The choice comes down to two questions asked honestly. First: how urgent is the screen? If you need a useful visual or wind barrier within two to three years, Leylandii is the answer and western red cedar is not a realistic substitute on that timescale. Second: how confident are you that you will clip the hedge consistently, at least twice a year, for as long as it is in place? If the honest answer is "reasonably confident", Leylandii is manageable, though never entirely forgiving. If the honest answer is "less certain", western red cedar's wider safety margin on harder cuts is worth the slower start and the extra plant cost.
A third consideration, specific to properties with houses close to a boundary: if a Leylandii hedge at 2m or more will be visible from a neighbouring dwelling, the risk of a Part 8 complaint is real. Western red cedar, growing more slowly and requiring less aggressive annual maintenance to stay compact, is the lower-risk choice in that situation even if it costs more and takes longer to establish.
Planting and establishment
Both conifers are planted from container or cell-grown stock, available year-round, though a late autumn to early spring planting (October to March) gives the best establishment on the free-draining chalky soils around Goodnestone. Space plants at 60cm for a hedge that closes within five to seven years for western red cedar, or within three to four years for Leylandii. Both species establish better with a weed-suppressing mulch for the first three years: 7-10cm of wood chip kept clear of the stems. Water both species in during a dry first spring, since chalk-over-clay soils can dry out quickly in east Kent from April onwards.
In the first two growing seasons, do not clip the leading shoot. Clip lightly on the sides to encourage basal density, but let the plants reach their intended height naturally before topping. The goal in the early years is depth and density of growth from the base upwards, not a clean face at height.
Clipping schedule once the hedge is established
Leylandii maintained as a formal screen needs clipping two to three times per year once it has reached its final dimensions: once in late May or early June on the new spring flush, and again in late August or early September after the main summer growth. If growth rate is high in a particular year, a third light trim in July may be needed. Miss a year and the hedge puts on 60-90cm that must be removed in catch-up cuts which push further into the green zone each time.
Western red cedar at final dimensions needs clipping once in late spring (May to early June) and once in late August. The lower growth rate means that in most years, two clips are sufficient to keep the face tidy, and if one is missed, the impact on the hedge is less severe. The RHS recommends spring and late summer clipping for Thuja plicata grown as a hedge, and this matches what I find in practice on the sites I maintain.
High-hedge law and conifer screens: what the Act actually says
The Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003, Part 8, gives neighbours the right to complain to the local council about an evergreen or semi-evergreen hedge over 2m that is adversely affecting the reasonable enjoyment of their property. Leylandii hedges are the most common subject of these complaints nationally. A formal complaint to Dover District Council currently costs £450 to file. If the complaint is upheld, the council issues a remedial notice specifying the required height, which the hedge owner must comply with and maintain year on year. Failure to comply can result in prosecution. The 2m threshold is not a blanket cap: the council can specify a higher or lower height depending on the specific case. Replacing a Leylandii screen with western red cedar does not remove the high-hedge risk, since Thuja is also an evergreen conifer, but its slower growth and lower maintenance requirement reduce the practical risk of the hedge getting ahead of you and becoming a problem. The full process for a high-hedge complaint is covered in the guide on neighbour high-hedge complaints, linked below.
Nesting season and conifer hedges
Dense conifer hedges, both Leylandii and western red cedar, are common nesting habitat for wrens, dunnocks, goldcrests and blackbirds. The Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1, makes it an offence to intentionally damage or destroy an active wild bird's nest. The practical caution window is 1 March to 31 August, extending into September for late broods. Trimming established conifer hedges in late August and again in late May or early June, as recommended above, falls on the edge of or outside this window. If any maintenance trimming is needed during the core nesting period, a careful visual check of the hedge face for nests before starting is essential. For renovation cuts or removal work, plan and carry out clearance in late autumn through to the end of February.
Local note: planting a conifer screen near Goodnestone and Chillenden
The chalky boulder clay around Goodnestone village and Chillenden suits both conifers reasonably well on the better-drained plots. The higher ground directly around the park and church drains well and poses few establishment risks for either species. On lower-lying ground in the bowl between Goodnestone and Chillenden, where water can sit through November to February, neither Leylandii nor western red cedar is ideal. On those sites I would usually suggest a native boundary hedge of hawthorn, blackthorn and field maple as a more resilient long-term option, with the same evergreen screening role met by specific planted bays of native evergreen alternatives rather than a conifer run. A conifer hedge also sits visually differently from the farmland character of the area around Goodnestone Park, which is worth considering if the hedge is visible from the road or from the park setting.
Related guides
Not sure which conifer suits your specific site?
If the plot is awkward, overlooked, or close to a neighbouring property, it is worth talking through the options before committing to a planting. Call 07763 100 477, WhatsApp the same number, or email hello@goodnestonehedges.co.uk.
Sources: RHS, Thuja plicata plant profile (rhs.org.uk); RHS guidance on hedges: nuisance and overgrown; Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003, Part 8 (high hedges); Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1; Dover District Council, high-hedge complaint guidance; Deepdale Trees, Thuja plicata growing notes; Woodland Trust, conifer hedging guidance.