Portuguese laurel or cherry laurel for a formal hedge: the honest choice for Goodnestone gardens
Both laurels give you a dense, evergreen boundary hedge that holds its shape under clipping. Both are faster to establish than yew or hornbeam. And yet the two plants behave quite differently in practice, especially on the chalky, free-draining ground around Goodnestone and Chillenden. Cherry laurel is cheaper, faster and everywhere. Portuguese laurel is neater, more disease-resistant and better suited to chalky soil. Neither is obviously right for every situation, and the decision is worth making deliberately before you spend money on plants and labour.
What both laurels have in common
Both are members of the genus Prunus, both are broadleaved evergreens, and both are widely planted throughout east Kent as formal garden hedges, boundary screens and kitchen-garden enclosures. Both establish well from container-grown or bare-root stock planted between October and March. Both tolerate clipping into a formal shape and, in most UK conditions, neither will die back after a hard renovation cut into older wood (unlike Leylandii, which does not recover from cuts into brown growth). Both are used in the formal gardens around Goodnestone Park and in the walled and enclosed boundaries throughout the villages around Wingham. If you are simply looking for a faster, denser evergreen hedge than yew or hornbeam will give you in the first five years, either laurel can do that job. The question is which one suits your specific ground, your maintenance capacity and your tolerance for the way each plant behaves over time.
The decision: Portuguese laurel or cherry laurel?
Pros of cherry laurel (Prunus laurocerasus)
- Faster establishment than Portuguese laurel. In good growing conditions, cherry laurel puts on 30-60cm of growth per year, and can exceed that in a warm, wet season on rich, deep soil. A row of cell-grown plants at 45cm spacing will produce a useful visual screen within two to three growing seasons and a substantial hedge within four. If rapid screening is the overriding priority, cherry laurel gets you there faster.
- Lower purchase cost. Cherry laurel plants are among the cheapest evergreen hedging options available in the UK. Cell-grown and root-balled stock is widely sold by hedging nurseries at £1-£3 per plant in sizes that establish quickly, making it accessible for long boundary runs where plant material cost is a real constraint.
- Very widely available. Cherry laurel is stocked by virtually every UK garden centre and hedging supplier. There is no waiting on specialist orders or planning ahead for autumn delivery as there sometimes is with Portuguese laurel. If the decision is made in spring or early summer and you want to plant in October, cherry laurel will be there.
- Tolerates deep shade. Cherry laurel performs reliably on north-facing boundaries and under the canopy of established trees, where many hedging plants struggle. If part of the planting line runs in heavy shade, cherry laurel maintains reasonable growth and density where Portuguese laurel would thin out.
- Cold-hardy. Cherry laurel is rated RHS H6 (hardy to around -20°C), making it reliable through the coldest UK winters. For open, exposed positions on high ground between Goodnestone and Nonington, this makes no practical difference in most years, but in an exceptional winter it is a meaningful margin.
Cons of cherry laurel (Prunus laurocerasus)
- The large leaves tear under a hedge trimmer. Cherry laurel leaves are typically 10-20cm long. When a rotary blade hedge trimmer passes through them, the cut surface is large and the leaf tissue tears rather than slicing cleanly. The result is a hedge face full of brown-edged, dying leaf sections that remain visible for four to six weeks after clipping. On a formal hedge where appearance matters, this is a significant drawback. The correct tool for a neat finish is loppers or hand shears cutting individual stems, which is far more time-consuming on a long run. Most contractors will use a trimmer anyway and accept the temporary browning; if you are paying by the hour for a neat result, that has a cost.
- Vigorous and can become invasive in adjoining ground. Cherry laurel produces berries freely, which birds eat and deposit throughout the garden and beyond. Seedlings establish readily in hedgerows, woodland edges and rough ground. In several European countries it is classified as an invasive species for this reason. Around the field boundaries and hedgerows near Goodnestone and Chillenden, a garden cherry laurel hedge that seeds into the adjacent farmland hedgerow is a legitimate concern, particularly given that the Hedgerow Regulations 1997 protect many of those boundaries.
- Prone to shothole disease. Stigmina carpophila is a fungal pathogen that attacks cherry laurel leaves, causing small, circular brown spots that then fall out, leaving the foliage full of holes. A hedge with established shothole disease looks tatty through mid to late summer, which is exactly the season when a formal boundary hedge should look its best. The disease is widespread in the UK and virtually impossible to eradicate from an existing hedge. Copper-based fungicide treatments slow it, but do not eliminate it. Portuguese laurel is significantly more resistant.
- Can struggle on very well-drained chalk in dry summers. On the chalky boulder clay above the 30m contour around Goodnestone village, cherry laurel can show leaf yellowing and marginal scorch from July onwards in a dry year. The chalk extracts moisture quickly in warm weather, and cherry laurel is less adapted to that stress than Portuguese laurel. On the lower, heavier ground it performs better, but on the freer-draining plots it is worth considering the extra establishment support needed.
- Berries are toxic, particularly to horses and livestock. Cherry laurel fruit contains prunasin, a cyanogenic glycoside that is poisonous if eaten in quantity. For a boundary hedge adjacent to a paddock or field grazing around Knowlton or Rowling, this is a genuine safety consideration. Portuguese laurel berries are also mildly toxic, but the volume of fruit and the specific chemistry make cherry laurel the higher-risk species in a livestock context.
Pros of Portuguese laurel (Prunus lusitanica)
- Smaller leaves clip cleanly. Portuguese laurel leaves are typically 5-12cm long, significantly smaller than cherry laurel. A hedge trimmer cuts through them cleanly without tearing, leaving a neat, pale cut surface that is proportionately small and weathers to green within a week or two rather than remaining brown-edged for a month. The formal appearance of a clipped Portuguese laurel hedge is noticeably neater than cherry laurel immediately after cutting and throughout the season.
- Performs better on chalky, free-draining soils. Prunus lusitanica handles alkaline, well-drained ground more reliably than cherry laurel, and is less prone to the leaf yellowing that can affect cherry laurel on thin chalk soils in dry summers. The chalky boulder clay around Goodnestone village suits Portuguese laurel well, and on the higher, better-drained plots it is the more resilient long-term choice of the two.
- More resistant to shothole disease. Portuguese laurel is significantly less susceptible to Stigmina carpophila than cherry laurel. Its foliage remains presentable through the full growing season, which matters for a formal boundary hedge that is on view from a garden or road. In the long run, this difference in disease resistance is one of the more practically important distinctions between the two species.
- Flowers in June and July. Portuguese laurel produces long, fragrant racemes of small white flowers in early summer, typically June to early July in east Kent. These are attractive in their own right and provide a useful pollen and nectar source for bees and hoverflies at a time of year when many hedging plants are not flowering. It is unusual for a formal clipped hedge to offer this kind of seasonal wildlife value, and it is a genuine advantage over cherry laurel.
- Lower maintenance demand once established. At final dimensions, a Portuguese laurel hedge can usually be kept in good order with one clip per year, in late August after the main flush of new growth. Its slower growth rate means that missing a season does not result in the same degree of overshoot that an unclipped cherry laurel hedge produces. For owners who want a formal hedge with less year-round management commitment, Portuguese laurel is the easier long-term proposition.
Cons of Portuguese laurel (Prunus lusitanica)
- Slower to produce a screen. Portuguese laurel typically grows 20-40cm per year in UK conditions, around half the rate of cherry laurel on a comparable site. A useful visual screen from a row of 60cm plants takes three to four growing seasons rather than two to three. On a new boundary where privacy is needed quickly, that extra year matters.
- More expensive to buy. Portuguese laurel plants typically cost £3-£6 per cell-grown plant, compared with £1-£3 for cherry laurel at the same size. On a 30-metre boundary run at 45cm spacing, that difference is £90-£270 in plant material alone. On a longer run, or where the hedge is on both sides of a property, the cost gap is meaningful.
- Less widely stocked at local outlets. Portuguese laurel is available from specialist hedging nurseries and online suppliers, but it is less likely to appear on the shelves of a local garden centre than cherry laurel. Planning ahead for delivery in autumn or early spring is more necessary, and last-minute sourcing in the wrong season is harder.
- Less cold-hardy than cherry laurel. Portuguese laurel is rated around RHS H5 (hardy to approximately -15°C), which is perfectly adequate for east Kent in all but the most exceptional winters. However, on an exposed, north- or east-facing position on high ground that catches cold drying winds in February, the foliage can bronze or scorch on the exposed face. It usually recovers when growth resumes in spring, but it can look ragged in late winter.
- Less suited to heavy shade. On a heavily shaded boundary, particularly under a dense existing tree canopy, cherry laurel's tolerance of low light gives it an advantage. Portuguese laurel prefers an open to semi-shaded position and will thin out and lose its lower foliage density in deep, persistent shade.
Which suits the ground around Goodnestone?
On the free-draining, chalky plots that make up most of the higher ground around Goodnestone village, Chillenden and Knowlton, Portuguese laurel is the better long-term choice. Its stronger performance on alkaline, well-drained ground means it establishes more reliably and sustains density and health through dry summers without the leaf yellowing that cherry laurel can show. Its disease resistance also reduces the likelihood of an unsightly hedge face through mid-summer, which is when a formal boundary is most visible.
Cherry laurel remains the rational choice where the urgency of screening outweighs the long-term appearance difference, where the boundary is in heavy shade, or where the budget for plant material is a real constraint. On the lower, heavier ground between Goodnestone and Wingham where the soil holds more moisture, cherry laurel also establishes without the same chalk-stress risk. The honest answer is that on most of the well-drained plots around the village, Portuguese laurel will reward you for the extra initial cost within three to four years, and you will not be dealing with shothole disease or clipping-damage browning for the following two decades.
Near Goodnestone Park and Holy Cross Church, the finer leaf texture and seasonal white flowers of Portuguese laurel sit more comfortably within the character of a historic formal garden setting than the coarser, heavier-leaved cherry laurel. If the hedge is adjacent to a listed wall, a paddock fence or a lane where the planting will be seen at close range from a public viewpoint, the visual quality of a well-clipped Portuguese laurel hedge is noticeably higher.
Cutting technique
Portuguese laurel can be cut cleanly with a hedge trimmer fitted with a long blade, working along the face in a single pass. The small leaves and firm stem structure accept the cutting action well. One clip in late August is generally sufficient for a maintained hedge at final dimensions. For a hedge being taken to a new shape or reduced in height, late winter pruning with loppers before the spring flush is the normal approach.
Cherry laurel ideally should be pruned with loppers or secateurs, cutting individual stems rather than trimming across the leaf surface. This is the advice of the RHS and most experienced hedging contractors, and it avoids the brown-edged cut-leaf appearance that trimmer use produces. In practice, most contractors use a trimmer for speed and accept the temporary browning. If you are maintaining the hedge yourself and appearance through summer matters, the hand-pruning approach produces a significantly neater result, though it takes considerably longer on any run above a few metres. One clip per year in late August is sufficient for Portuguese laurel. Cherry laurel at final dimensions usually needs two: one after the main spring flush (mid-May to early June) and one in late August.
Establishment on chalk
Both laurels establish best when planted between October and March. On the chalky boulder clay around Goodnestone, work in a bucket of organic matter (garden compost or well-rotted manure) per planting hole before setting the plant. This improves moisture retention in the upper soil layer, which both species need through their first two summers before roots reach deeper into the soil profile. Space plants at 40-50cm for Portuguese laurel and 45-60cm for cherry laurel, for a hedge that closes within four to five years or three to four years respectively.
In both cases, apply a 7-10cm wood chip mulch along the base of the planting line for the first three years, kept clear of the stems themselves, to suppress competing grass and weeds and retain soil moisture. Water both species through any dry spell in their first spring and summer: on chalk, spring drought can set back newly planted laurels by a full growing season. Do not clip the leading shoots in the first two seasons; allow plants to reach their intended height naturally and concentrate early maintenance on lightly trimming the sides to encourage basal density.
Nesting season and laurel hedges
Dense laurel hedges of both species are common nesting sites for blackbirds, robins, wrens and dunnocks. The Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1, makes it an offence to intentionally damage or destroy an active wild bird's nest. The practical caution window is 1 March to 31 August, extending into September for late broods. The recommended clipping window for both laurels (late August) falls at the edge of this period. If a trim is needed before late August, a visual check for active nests along the hedge face before starting is essential. Renovation cuts or removal work should be planned for late autumn through to the end of February.
Related guides
- Overgrown laurel hedge: hard renovation prune, or remove and replant?
- Box blight: treat and keep the box, or remove it and replant with something else?
- Hornbeam or beech for a formal hedge: which suits the chalky soil around Goodnestone?
- Native hawthorn or formal yew: which hedge suits your plot?
- Photinia Red Robin: is it worth planting as a formal hedge near Goodnestone?
Not sure which laurel suits your specific site?
Soil type, shade, aspect and how quickly you need a screen all affect the answer. Call 07763 100 477, WhatsApp the same number, or email hello@goodnestonehedges.co.uk and I can take a look at the plot before you commit to plants.
Sources: RHS, Prunus lusitanica plant profile and growing guide (rhs.org.uk); RHS, Prunus laurocerasus growing guide; RHS guidance on hedge trimming: timing and technique; Hedging Plants Direct, Portuguese laurel vs cherry laurel comparison; Ashridge Trees, Portuguese laurel growing notes; Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1; Hedgerow Regulations 1997.