Elder in a native hedge: manage it on a coppice rotation, leave it, or clear it out?
Elder (Sambucus nigra) turns up in almost every mixed native hedgerow around Goodnestone, Chillenden and Knowlton. It seeds itself in from bird droppings, grows faster than the hawthorn around it, and within a few years it can dominate a section of hedge. Most people either ignore it and hope for the best, or pull it out at the first opportunity. Neither is usually the right call. The real question is whether the management cost of keeping elder in the hedge is worth what it gives back, and that turns out to be a more honest trade-off than it first looks.
The decision: three ways to handle elder in a mixed native hedge
Elder is not harmful to the hedge in the way that bramble or ivy might appear to be. The problem is specific: left unmanaged on fertile chalky soil, elder becomes a wide, multi-stemmed shrub with a spreading canopy that shades and gradually crowds out the hawthorn and blackthorn growing beside it. A section that started as a balanced mix can, within 8 to 10 years, become an elder thicket with a thin, gappy base and the structural species struggling at the edges. The decision is whether to manage elder on its own terms, leave it alone, or remove it.
Pros of managing elder on a periodic coppice rotation
- Elder's wildlife contribution is genuinely substantial and timed to fill gaps that other hedge species miss. The flat-topped cream flower clusters appear in late May to June, providing nectar to hoverflies, bees and butterflies at a point in the season when other hedgerow blossom has already finished. The dark berries ripen in August to September: among the first hedge fruits available to blackbirds, song thrushes, robins, blackcaps and starlings as the summer food supply runs down. Few single native shrubs offer both a flower crop and a berry crop of this quality in the same season.
- Elder responds well to hard cutting. Cut to near ground level in the dormant season, it regrows vigorously from the base and returns to full fruit-bearing size within three to four years. The coppice cycle keeps it from crowding the hawthorn while maintaining its ecological contribution.
- No establishment cost. Elder seeds itself freely from bird-dropped seed and costs nothing to include in the hedge. Keeping it managed is cheaper than removing and replanting with purchased species.
- Managed elder fits naturally into a professional hedge lay cycle. When a hedge contractor lays a section, elder stools are coppiced to ground level as a routine part of the work, so the management cost is absorbed rather than added.
- Elder is well adapted to the chalky boulder clay around Goodnestone. It tolerates free-draining alkaline soils without amendment and does not compete for moisture in the same way that a beech or hornbeam would in a dry east Kent summer.
Cons of managing elder on a periodic coppice rotation
- The coppice rotation adds a management layer that the rest of a clipped hawthorn hedge does not need. Elder cannot simply be trimmed annually alongside the hawthorn. It needs periodic hard cutting back to the base, which is a different task and a different schedule. If you are managing the hedge yourself, this means remembering to treat elder stools differently and doing the work in a separate pass.
- On fertile chalky soil, elder regrows fast. An elder coppiced to ground level in January can reach 1.5 metres by September of the same year and regain dominance within 4 to 5 years. The rotation requires genuine follow-through, not a one-off cut.
- Where elder has spread to several positions along a hedge, the accumulated coppice work in a single winter can become a significant task. Multiple large stools cut hard and the resulting arisings cleared is more labour than it sounds.
- Elder stools at the base of a hedge leave gaps in the lower structure in the year or two immediately after coppicing. This is temporary, but it is a consideration for a field boundary hedge that is also meant to be stock-proof.
Pros of leaving elder to grow unchecked
- No effort or cost in the short term.
- Full wildlife benefit throughout the period before the plant begins to dominate: flowers, berries, shelter and nest sites at no management overhead.
- Elder provides useful early bulk in a young hedge, helping close gaps quickly while the slower hawthorn and blackthorn establish.
Cons of leaving elder to grow unchecked
- Without management on good chalk soil, elder becomes the dominant plant in the sections it occupies within 8 to 12 years. Its canopy shades the hawthorn, which progressively thins and dies back. The result is not a mixed hedge but an elder thicket, which is far less structurally sound, far less stock-proof at the base, and harder to restore later.
- A hedge section that has gone over to elder is not easy to recover. The structural species (hawthorn, blackthorn) that die out beneath the elder canopy do not return without active replanting.
Pros of clearing elder out entirely
- Removes the management complexity. A hedge section with no elder can be managed as a single clipped entity with one maintenance regime.
- Gives the structural species (hawthorn, blackthorn, field maple) full light and growing space throughout the hedge profile.
- Appropriate where elder has already caused significant structural damage and the priority is rebuilding density and stock-proof cover from bare stems upward.
Cons of clearing elder out entirely
- Elder is difficult to fully eradicate. Cut to ground level without follow-up treatment, the root system resproutes strongly and the plant returns within two growing seasons. Removing elder cleanly requires cutting back, allowing regrowth, and cutting again repeatedly over two to three seasons, or treating freshly cut stumps with a translocated herbicide. This is more work than a managed coppice rotation.
- Clearing elder removes one of the most significant single contributors to a hedge's ecological calendar. The late-summer berry crop in particular has no easy replacement in a chalky east Kent hedgerow. Blackbirds and song thrushes that move to a hedgerow for autumn berries do not discriminate between sites: they go where the food is.
- Once cleared, elder will return from bird-spread seed within 5 to 10 years anyway, unless you actively clear every seedling as it appears. The clearance effort buys time, not a permanent solution.
What I recommend for hedges around Goodnestone and Chillenden
For field boundary hedges on the chalky boulder clay of this area, managing elder on a periodic coppice rotation is the right approach in the large majority of cases. The wildlife value it provides is too significant to throw away, the management cost is real but modest if absorbed into a regular hedge maintenance programme, and the alternative of leaving it unmanaged leads to structural decline that costs far more to reverse.
The practical cycle: identify the elder stools in the hedge in winter when the leaves are down (the pale, corky bark and pithy stems are distinctive). Cut each stool to 10 to 15 centimetres from ground level every 4 to 6 years, in the dormant season from November to February. Clear and remove the cut stems as arisings. If the hedge is being laid professionally, direct the contractor to coppice the elder stools at the same time rather than laying them into the pleachers.
The one situation where clearance is the better answer: a long section of hedge where elder has already taken over, the structural species below are dead or nearly dead, and the priority is rebuilding a stock-proof base. Here, clear the elder, replant the section with bare-root hawthorn and blackthorn whips in the same dormant season, protect them with spiral guards, and allow elder to self-seed back in naturally over the following years rather than deliberately including it. Within a decade you will have a balanced section again, with elder in the mix but not dominant.
Practical notes for east Kent conditions
On the chalky free-draining soils around Goodnestone, elder tends to establish at the wetter, slightly lower points in a field boundary, where moisture lingers longer. This often means elder concentrates in the dips and corner junctions of a hedge run rather than spreading uniformly. If that is the pattern you are seeing, the coppice rotation work can be targeted at those specific points rather than applied across the whole hedge length.
Elder berries contain compounds that are mildly toxic when eaten raw in quantity (the unripe berries and all parts of the stems and leaves are more so). This is rarely a practical problem in a field boundary context, but worth noting if the hedge runs alongside a garden used by children or if livestock have access.
Dormice and bank voles eat both the flowers and the berries of elder, so a hedge with established elder in the mix has year-round habitat value beyond what is visible from the outside. The Goodnestone area has farmland hedgerows that have been maintained without major disturbance for generations, and the elder in them is part of that continuity.
Does cutting elder back count as hedge work for nesting season purposes?
Yes. Coppicing elder within a hedge line is hedge work, and the standard caution window applies. Under section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, intentionally damaging or destroying an active wild bird's nest is an offence carrying an unlimited fine. The practical caution window is 1 March to 31 August, extending into September for late broods. The dormant-season coppice window of November to February sits entirely outside this window and is the correct time for the work in any case. Elder berries are typically stripped by birds well before November, so cutting from that point onwards does not remove an active food source.
Related guides
Not sure what you are dealing with in your hedge?
I quote for hedge work across Goodnestone, Chillenden, Knowlton, Rowling and out towards Wingham. If you want a view on what is in your boundary hedge and how best to manage it, call 07763 100 477, send a WhatsApp to the same number or email hello@goodnestonehedges.co.uk. Fixed price, no hourly rate.
Sources: Woodland Trust, native hedgerow species guidance for Sambucus nigra; Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust, elder species notes 2025; The Conservation Volunteers, tree library entry for elder; Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1; Ashridge Trees, mixed-hedge species management guidance.