Blackthorn or hawthorn as the backbone of a new field boundary hedge near Goodnestone?
When you are planting a new thorny native hedge along a field boundary around Goodnestone, Chillenden or Knowlton, the question that actually matters is not whether to plant a thorny species, but which one to lead with. Both blackthorn (Prunus spinosa) and hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna) are native, wildlife-rich and genuinely stock-proof once established. The choice between them shapes how the hedge behaves, how safely it can be worked, and how reliably it establishes on the chalky boulder clay of this part of east Kent.
What they share
Both are native UK shrubs with a long history on the hedgelines of this landscape. Both flower and berry generously for wildlife, both take bare-root whips planted October to March at 30 to 45 cm spacing in a double staggered row, and both tolerate the alkaline, free-draining conditions that the chalk underlying Goodnestone, Chillenden and Knowlton imposes. If you plant either and manage them correctly in years one to three, you get a working boundary hedge. The question is which gives you fewer problems and which delivers the specific benefit you are after.
The decision: blackthorn or hawthorn as the framework species?
Pros of leading with blackthorn
- Earlier and denser base growth through root suckering. Blackthorn naturally spreads by underground runners, throwing up new stems along the hedge base over the first five to eight years. On a working farm boundary, this suckering fills gaps, thickens the bottom of the hedge and creates the impenetrable base that stock cannot push through. A hawthorn hedge achieves the same effect only through careful formative pruning and, eventually, traditional hedgelaying.
- Flowers three to five weeks ahead of hawthorn. Blackthorn blossom opens in mid-March, when hawthorn is still in bud. On the exposed chalky arable land between Goodnestone and Chillenden, the early white flowers are one of the most important early-season pollinator resources in the hedgeline: bumble bee queens leaving hibernation in late February and early March rely on early blossom before much else is available. The gap between blackthorn and hawthorn flowering is four to six weeks in a normal Kent spring.
- Sloe berries extend the feeding season for birds. Blackthorn produces sloes, which ripen from late September. Hawthorn haws follow in October. If you have both species in the hedgeline, thrushes, fieldfares and redwings arriving from October through to February can work the hedge across a much longer window than hawthorn alone provides.
- Exceptional thorns. Blackthorn thorns are 1.5 to 3 cm long, completely rigid, and project directly from the main stems rather than from side branches. A mature blackthorn section of hedge is genuinely impenetrable to cattle and sheep, and the thorns deter casual trespass more effectively than hawthorn. For boundaries alongside public footpaths and open countryside, this is a genuine security advantage.
- Tolerates poorly drained corners. Where the field boundary crosses a low-lying wetter patch, blackthorn handles short periods of waterlogging better than hawthorn. Around Knowlton and the lower-lying margins around Chillenden, those wet corners are common enough to matter.
Cons of leading with blackthorn
- Persistent, aggressive suckering into adjacent land. The same suckering that thickens the hedge base also spreads outward into the field margin, garden or neighbouring plot if it is not controlled. On arable or mown grass, the field-side suckers get cut back regularly and the problem manages itself. On an unmown margin, or on a garden boundary, blackthorn suckers can advance 50 to 100 cm per year. Managing this is an ongoing annual commitment that a hawthorn hedge does not impose.
- Thorns that cause serious puncture wounds. Blackthorn thorns are brittle at the tip, and they snap off in gloves, skin and clothing rather than bending clear. The broken thorn fragment causes a deep, narrow wound that is prone to infection, including by Propionibacterium acnes, a slow-growing bacterium carried on the thorn surface. This is sometimes called "blackthorn disease" in rural medicine and surgery contexts: a minor scratch that becomes a painful, spreading infection days later. Any contractor working closely with a blackthorn-dominated hedge needs appropriate heavy gloves and puncture-resistant clothing. The injury risk is real and documented in UK GP and hospital settings.
- Establishment on thin chalk soil is uncertain. UK hedging nurseries give conflicting advice here. Some list blackthorn as tolerant of chalk; others state it does not suit chalk conditions. The chalky boulder clay around Goodnestone is free-draining but moderately fertile. My own experience on east Kent farmland is that blackthorn establishes acceptably where the topsoil has reasonable depth (30 cm or more) but struggles in patches where the chalk sits close to the surface and the soil dries to almost nothing in a dry June. Hawthorn is consistently more reliable across the range of conditions you actually find along a typical Goodnestone or Chillenden boundary.
- Harder to hedge-lay than hawthorn. The traditional South of England hedgelaying style is built around hawthorn as the main pleacher species. Blackthorn stems are shorter-jointed and more brittle, which makes laying them slower and risks splitting at the pleach. A hedge layer quoted on blackthorn-heavy material will charge more per metre than for a clean hawthorn run. If the long-term plan for the boundary includes traditional laying in fifteen to twenty years, a hawthorn-dominant hedge is the more practical starting point.
- Can dominate other species in the mix. If blackthorn forms more than about 25 to 30 percent of a mixed native hedge, its suckering tends to outcompete slower-establishing species like spindle and dogwood in the early years. Keeping it in the mix at 10 to 15 percent is manageable. Leading with it at majority proportions while trying to maintain other species alongside it requires active management of the suckering that most people underestimate at planting time.
Pros of leading with hawthorn
- Consistently reliable on chalky boulder clay. Hawthorn is the backbone species of the east Kent hedgeline landscape precisely because it has a long track record on the alkaline, free-draining soils of this area. It tolerates pH above 7.5, handles summer drought once past year two without supplementary watering, and establishes at a steady and predictable rate across the range of soil conditions you encounter along a typical Goodnestone field boundary. There are very few east Kent sites where hawthorn fails to establish when the basic planting and aftercare steps are followed.
- No persistent suckering. Hawthorn stays where you plant it. The hedge line does not migrate sideways into the field or garden, and there is no annual suckering programme to manage. This makes it significantly less demanding to maintain on a long boundary, especially when the adjacent land is a garden rather than arable ground that is regularly cultivated or flailed.
- Easier and safer to work with. Hawthorn thorns are shorter (typically 1 to 2 cm) and sit on side branches rather than main stems, which means ordinary thorn-proof gloves provide adequate protection for most cutting and pruning work. Contractors working hawthorn-dominant hedges routinely, including myself, can work at a steadier pace with a lower puncture risk than when working into blackthorn-heavy material.
- The standard framework species for hedgelaying. All traditional South of England hedgelaying guidance, the BTCV Hedging handbook, and the National Hedgelaying Society's training materials treat hawthorn as the default pleacher species. If the boundary will eventually be laid, hawthorn gives you the cleanest starting material.
- Widely available and inexpensive. Bare-root hawthorn whips at 30 to 45 cm grade are available from multiple UK suppliers throughout the bare-root season, often at 25p to 40p per plant in modest quantities. Availability is rarely a constraint. Blackthorn whips are less widely stocked by mainstream farm suppliers, and good-quality native provenance material needs advance ordering from specialist hedging nurseries.
Cons of leading with hawthorn
- Takes longer to achieve a stock-proof base without hedgelaying. A hawthorn hedge does not thicken naturally at the base through suckering, so a young hawthorn run has a period in years two to four where it is above-knee height but still has enough gaps at the base to let rabbits and even small livestock through. This is managed by correct formative pruning: cutting back by a third in the first winter, establishing a bushy rather than whippy shape from the start. A blackthorn hedge fills those gaps faster and with less deliberate intervention.
- Flowers later, missing the earliest-spring pollinator window. Hawthorn blossom is abundant and genuinely important for insects in May, but it misses the mid-March to late-April period when early pollinators are most in need of forage. For a boundary where early blossom is a specific priority, hawthorn alone leaves a five-week gap that blackthorn or flowering blackthorn-proportion plants in the mix would fill.
- Haws ripen in October, earlier in the season than sloes. Hawthorn haws are stripped by thrushes and fieldfares within a few weeks of ripening, typically October to November. Without blackthorn, spindle or other late-fruiting species in the mix, the hedge's food value for wintering birds drops sharply after November. This is a minor concern on a working farm boundary but worth considering on a garden or mixed-use plot.
What the evidence says about chalk soil
Several well-regarded UK native hedging nurseries, including Ashridge Trees and Scot Plants Direct, list blackthorn as tolerant of chalky soil, alongside hawthorn. But other mixed-hedge guides note that blackthorn performs less consistently on chalk than on heavier clay. In my direct experience along east Kent boundaries, blackthorn on shallow chalk does establish, but it is more variable plant to plant and more dependent on soil depth than hawthorn. Where the chalk sits within 15 to 20 cm of the surface, as it does in exposed field corners on the higher ground between Goodnestone and Knowlton, I have seen blackthorn whips fail to thrive in a way that hawthorn plants in the same row do not. The safest approach on this soil type is hawthorn as the majority backbone, with blackthorn as a secondary species at 10 to 20 percent, placed in the sections of the boundary where the soil profile has better depth.
The practical recommendation for Goodnestone farmland
For most new field boundary hedges around Goodnestone, Chillenden and Knowlton, I recommend hawthorn as the dominant framework species at 60 to 70 percent of the planting, with blackthorn at 10 to 20 percent in the wetter or lower sections of the boundary where its suckering and soil tolerance are actual advantages. That proportion gives you hawthorn's reliability on chalk, predictable management and hedgelaying suitability, while the blackthorn proportion delivers the early blossom and sloe berries that extend the hedge's wildlife value across the season. It also keeps the suckering manageable: 10 to 20 percent blackthorn in a well-managed hedge is not difficult to contain; 50 percent blackthorn requires meaningful annual attention.
The only situation where I would lead with blackthorn at majority proportions is a wet, heavy-soil boundary where fast stock-proofing of a low-lying field edge is the primary purpose and mechanical flailing will manage the field-side suckering routinely. That describes some of the valley bottoms and low-lying corners in the Wingham and Nonington direction, but it does not describe most of the chalky upland boundaries around Goodnestone village itself.
Clearance before planting: is there existing vegetation to remove?
If you are removing any existing boundary vegetation, a degraded old hedge or an established bramble run to prepare the ground for replanting, section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 applies. It is an offence to intentionally destroy an active wild bird's nest. The practical caution window for clearance work is 1 March to 31 August, extending into September for late broods in a warm year. Plan any clearance for January or February, before birds establish nests, then plant bare-root whips from October onwards once the new planting season opens. The planting itself does not disturb nesting birds: it is the clearance stage where the legal risk sits.
Countryside Stewardship species-mix requirements
If the holding is in or considering entry into a Countryside Stewardship or Sustainable Farming Incentive agreement, the Natural England BN11 "new native hedgerow" action and equivalent SFI prescriptions specify a minimum mixed native species hedge. A minimum of three to five native woody species is typically required. Both hawthorn and blackthorn count toward that species-mix requirement, alongside field maple, dog rose, spindle and dogwood. The exact species list and proportions accepted for payment eligibility are published in the current Natural England CS Manual and updated annually: check the current year's guidance before ordering plants, as the requirements shift between CS rounds. I am happy to discuss how a specific boundary would be structured to meet the requirements: call or WhatsApp 07763 100 477.
Related guides
Not sure which species mix suits your boundary?
Tell me the site: soil depth, what's adjacent, whether livestock are involved, and whether you are in or planning a stewardship scheme. I will give you a straight recommendation. Call 07763 100 477, WhatsApp the same number, or email hello@goodnestonehedges.co.uk.
Sources: Scot Plants Direct, "Hawthorn vs blackthorn: which native hedge is right for you?" (scotplantsdirect.co.uk); Ashridge Trees, native hedging species guides (ashridgetrees.co.uk); BTCV / TCV, Hedging: A Practical Conservation Handbook (3rd ed.); National Hedgelaying Society, species guidance (hedgelaying.org.uk); Natural England, Countryside Stewardship Manual (BN11 new native hedgerow action, current edition); Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1; RHS, Prunus spinosa and Crataegus monogyna species entries (rhs.org.uk); Woodland Trust, native hedgerow species guides (woodlandtrust.org.uk).