Ash dieback in a hedgerow tree: fell it now, or leave it to die standing?
More than a third of hedgerow trees in England are ash. Around Goodnestone, Chillenden and Knowlton the lanes are lined with them, and most are showing some level of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus dieback by now. The question I get asked most often is a simple one: do I take it down while it is still manageable, or leave it alone? There is no single right answer, and this is the honest trade-off.
The decision: fell proactively, or let the tree die standing naturally
Pros of proactive felling
- Safety is the clearest argument. Ash with significant dieback stops following the usual rules of timber mechanics: branches can shed without warning even on days with no wind, and a partially dead stem can fracture unpredictably. A standing dead ash near a public footpath, a road or a neighbouring building is a foreseeable hazard, and as the landowner you carry the duty of care.
- The cost is lower while the tree is still manageable to work on. Felling a standing tree with sound structure costs a fraction of an emergency callout after a failure, when the access is worse and the work is more dangerous.
- You control the timing. Felling now means the gap in the hedge line is on a planned schedule: you can replant a field maple, hazel or hawthorn standard in that gap the same autumn, before the boundary opens up and rabbit pressure fills it with nothing useful.
- If the tree is clearly dead or showing severe dieback (broadly, more than 50 per cent canopy loss), it may qualify for the dead-or-dangerous exemption from the felling licence requirement under the Forestry Act 1967. That simplifies the paperwork considerably, provided you have a professional arborist's written assessment on file.
Cons of proactive felling
- A fraction of infected ash trees show partial tolerance to the disease: the Forestry Commission's own research notes that around 5 per cent of ash display heritable resistance traits and may survive long-term. An ash showing moderate, stable dieback after three or four seasons may be one of those trees. Felling it removes that possibility permanently.
- Veteran hedgerow ash have ecological value that a newly planted replacement cannot replicate for decades. Cavities, fissured bark and the standing deadwood of a large, slow-dying ash support specialist beetles, bats, roosting owls and decades of lichen accumulation. A planted whip is a long way from that.
- For a living tree, even a diseased one, the Forestry Act 1967 normally requires a felling licence from the Forestry Commission before the tree is felled. The process is straightforward and usually free for single trees in response to disease, but it takes time to obtain and felling without it is an offence.
- If the ash stands within Goodnestone conservation area (the village boundary runs roughly along the lane to the church), section 211 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 requires you to give Dover District Council six weeks' written notice before felling or carrying out major pruning, unless the tree is provably dead or dangerous. The six-week wait is the same one I describe in the conservation area guide; it applies to hedgerow trees exactly as it applies to garden trees.
- Felling and disposal costs money. A hedgerow ash large enough to be a genuine hazard typically takes a full day's work and a chipper, so expect somewhere in the £400 to £900 range depending on access and stem size. The timber from a dieback-affected tree is best chipped or burned on site rather than removed for sale.
How to actually decide
I use three questions when I assess a hedgerow ash for a client around here. First: where does it sit relative to paths, roads and structures? An ash in the middle of a field boundary with no footpath within 20 metres, and no neighbouring property, is a very different risk profile from one overhanging a lane used daily. Second: what proportion of the canopy is gone? A tree at 20-30 per cent dieback may still provide years of value as it declines slowly; one at 60-70 per cent with visible cracks in the upper stem is a genuine hazard now. Third: does it have veteran features, cavities or bat roosting signs? If yes, the case for leaving it is stronger and the case for a formal bat survey before any felling is almost certain.
If the tree is close to a path or structure, shows over 50 per cent dieback, or has visible fractures in the stem, the case for proactive removal is clear. If it is well away from anything and still has significant live crown, the honest answer is often to monitor it for another season and reassess.
Does nesting season affect when you can fell?
Yes. The Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1, makes it an offence to intentionally damage or destroy an active wild bird's nest. Ash trees in hedgerows are used by spotted flycatchers, jackdaws, tawny owls and various tit species throughout the main nesting window: 1 March to 31 August, extending into September for late broods. If you are felling in that window, I check the crown for active nests before any chainsaw starts. A dead tree with no foliage can still shelter a nest in a cavity. The safest felling window is November to February.
The felling licence and section 211 in practice
Both rules apply regardless of who does the physical work. Getting the paperwork wrong on a tree in Goodnestone conservation area is an easy mistake to make, and Dover District Council does follow up on complaints about unlicensed tree work. For a tree that is clearly dead and dangerous, the dead-or-dangerous exemption to both rules exists, but you need a written arborist's assessment to rely on it. That document is worth getting before you start, not after.
For a living but diseased tree outside the conservation area, the Forestry Commission's approval process for ash dieback felling has been streamlined and is normally quick, but it still requires a formal application. I always recommend obtaining it before booking the work, not assuming it will be granted.
What to plant in the gap
The gap left by a felled hedgerow ash is worth replanting the same autumn if the timing allows. Field maple is my first recommendation for a replacement standard tree in this landscape: it is chalk-tolerant, native, has good autumn colour, and grows at a pace that closes the gap reasonably quickly without the vigour problems you get from a willow or poplar standard. A hazel coppice stool is a better fit if you want something lower and more hedge-compatible. A small-leaved lime standard is worth considering for the soil conditions around the Park boundary, where they appear naturally. I would not plant another ash for obvious reasons.
Related guides
Not sure where your ash stands on this decision?
Send a photo and a rough location to hello@goodnestonehedges.co.uk or call 07763 100 477. I can give you an honest read on whether the tree warrants action now, whether it needs a bat survey first, and what the notice requirements are for your specific site.
Sources: Forestry Commission Operations Note ON046a, Managing individual ash affected by dieback (gov.uk, 2020); Woodland Trust, ash dieback guidance (woodlandtrust.org.uk); Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1; Forestry Act 1967; Town and Country Planning Act 1990, section 211.